New York City Pizza

190 E Bay St #102, Charleston, SC 29401, USA 3.9 Stars on Google
Opening Hours
  • Monday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Tuesday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Wednesday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Thursday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Friday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Saturday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Directions Website
4.6Concerns reported

Out of 10.0 review consistency and reported experiences

2 Relevant Reviews
Latest: a year ago

AI Summary

Analyzed 2 reviews, including 0 WiseBites Members and 2 Google Users. Reviewers reported that one guest received a gluten‑free pizza and praised its taste, while another guest criticized the gluten‑free pizza as a tortilla‑based item and expressed dissatisfaction with price and portion size.

Was this summary helpful?

User Photos0

No photos yet

Add a review with photos to be the first to show what this restaurant looks like.

Leave a Review

Sign up to share your gluten-free experience with the community.

Sign Up to Review

Community Reviews 0

No community reviews yet

Be the first to share your gluten-free experience at this restaurant.

Mentioned Reviews From Google

"Don't be turned away by lower reviews because this place was fantastic! Not expecting this but we had some amazing food. They were out of stock of…"

Elaina P.
a year ago

"WHAT A JOKE PLACE. Gluten free pizza is tortilla shell with 4 pepperonis on it and charging $23 for it and you dont know what size it is until its…"

Tim C.
a year ago
Read full reviews on Google

Nearby Restaurants

Carmella's Cafe and Dessert Bar

Good signals

198 E Bay St STE 100, Charleston, SC 29401, USA

Analyzed 10 reviews (0 WiseBites Members, 10 Google Users). Reviewers reported a variety of gluten‑free desserts such as tarts, chocolate tart, and gelato‑dipped cookies, with most describing the taste as excellent or very good, while a few noted texture issues like a salty crust or hard edges. Guests mentioned that staff, including a server named Rebecca, answered gluten‑free questions knowledgeably and provided courteous service.

Based on 10 gluten-related reviews

Ruby Sunshine

Good signals

171 E Bay St, Charleston, SC 29401, USA

Analyzed 10 reviews, including 10 Google Users and 0 WiseBites Members. Reviewers reported a dedicated gluten‑free menu with many options and staff who were knowledgeable about cross‑contamination protocols. Some guests noted possible cross‑contamination, such as finding hair in a dish and acknowledging that contamination could still occur despite precautions; other guests highlighted prompt accommodation of gluten‑free requests and generally positive experiences with the gluten‑free offerings.

Based on 10 gluten-related reviews

Bakehouse Charleston

Mixed signals

160 E Bay St, Charleston, SC 29401, USA

Analyzed 1 review (0 WiseBites Premium Members, 0 WiseBites Members, 1 Google User). Reviewers reported that the establishment offered gluten‑free brownies and staff indicated they contained no gluten, though no special preparation was performed.

Based on 1 gluten-related review

Byrd's Famous Cookies

Mixed signals

43 S Market St, Charleston, SC 29401, USA

Analyzed 4 reviews (0 WiseBites Members, 4 Google Users). Reviewers reported a selection of gluten‑free cookies and noted that the gluten‑free cookies were as good as the regular ones. No reviewers mentioned specific kitchen protocols, dedicated gluten‑free preparation areas, or incidents of cross‑contamination.

Based on 4 gluten-related reviews

Pizzeria Di Giovanni

Mixed signals

40 N Market St, Charleston, SC 29401, USA

Analyzed 1 review (0 WiseBites Premium Members, 0 WiseBites Members, 1 Google User). Reviewers reported that a gluten‑free pizza was prepared after the kitchen had closed for the night, with no specific details on dedicated equipment or cross‑contamination protocols.

Based on 1 gluten-related review

Frannie & The Fox

Concerns reported

181 Church St, Charleston, SC 29401, USA

Analyzed 6 reviews (0 WiseBites Members, 6 Google Users). Reviewers reported that several guests experienced refusal or lack of gluten‑free menu options, with multiple mentions that the restaurant does not offer gluten‑free pasta or pizza. Guests mentioned that one reviewer found the staff accommodating for gluten intolerance.

Based on 6 gluten-related reviews

SearchExploreSavedChat