I Love NY Pizza

980 Birmingham Rd, Alpharetta, GA 30004, USA 4.4 Stars on Google
Opening Hours
  • Monday: 10:00 AM – 8:40 PM
  • Tuesday: 10:00 AM – 8:40 PM
  • Wednesday: 10:00 AM – 8:40 PM
  • Thursday: 10:00 AM – 8:40 PM
  • Friday: 10:00 AM – 8:40 PM
  • Saturday: 10:00 AM – 8:40 PM
  • Sunday: 10:00 AM – 8:40 PM
Directions Website
6.6Mixed signals

Out of 10.0 review consistency and reported experiences

1 Relevant Reviews
Latest: Edited 3 weeks ago

AI Summary

Analyzed 1 review (0 WiseBites Premium Members, 0 WiseBites Members, 1 Google User). Reviewers reported gluten‑free pizza options.

Was this summary helpful?

User Photos0

No photos yet

Add a review with photos to be the first to show what this restaurant looks like.

Leave a Review

Sign up to share your gluten-free experience with the community.

Sign Up to Review

Community Reviews 0

No community reviews yet

Be the first to share your gluten-free experience at this restaurant.

Mentioned Reviews From Google

"Great pizzas gluten free 😊 Fast delivery too!"

Eduardo B.
Edited 3 weeks ago
Read full reviews on Google

Nearby Restaurants

Your Pie Pizza

Mixed signals

2955 Bethany Bend #300, Milton, GA 30004, USA

Analyzed 10 reviews, 0 from WiseBites Members and 10 from Google Users. Reviewers reported gluten-free crust options and some noted staff willingness to accommodate gluten-free requests, but guests mentioned concerns about cross-contamination, including shared toppings and lack of proper training.

Based on 10 gluten-related reviews

Bryan's Place Pizza & Pasta - NY Style

Good signals

4910 Atlanta Hwy, Alpharetta, GA 30004, USA

Analyzed 1 review (0 WiseBites Premium Members, 0 WiseBites Members, 1 Google User). Reviewers reported that questions about gluten‑free options were answered reassuringly and that the gluten‑free pizza tasted wonderful.

Based on 1 gluten-related review

Peace Love and Pizza - Milton

Good signals

12640 Crabapple Rd #100, Milton, GA 30004, USA

Analyzed 10 reviews, 0 from WiseBites Members and 10 from Google Users. Reviewers reported a variety of gluten-free options, including cauliflower crust and gluten-free dough, with some mentioning a separate prep line for gluten-free items. Guests mentioned friendly and patient staff, with many praising the gluten-free pizza options.

Based on 10 gluten-related reviews

Campania Crabapple

Mixed signals

12635 Crabapple Rd #310, Milton, GA 30004, USA

Analyzed 4 reviews, including 0 WiseBites Premium Members and 0 WiseBites Members, and 4 Google Users. Reviewers reported a gluten‑free pizza that was undercooked and described as prefabricated dough. Guests mentioned that the restaurant offers gluten‑free options and that several found them satisfactory.

Based on 4 gluten-related reviews

Firehouse Subs Deerfield

Concerns reported

13087 GA-9 Ste 930, Milton, GA 30004, USA

Analyzed 2 reviews, 0 from WiseBites Members and 2 from Google Users. Reviewers reported inconsistent gluten-free experiences, with one guest mentioning a lack of gluten-free bread options and another noting successful accommodation of gluten-free orders for a catering event.

Based on 2 gluten-related reviews

Ippolito's - Alpharetta

Mixed signals

12850 Alpharetta Hwy #2500, Alpharetta, GA 30004, USA

Analyzed 3 reviews (0 WiseBites Premium Members, 0 WiseBites Members, 3 Google Users). Reviewers reported gluten free pizza and other gluten free menu options are available. Guests mentioned that staff gave incorrect information about gluten allergies in one instance.

Based on 3 gluten-related reviews

SearchExploreSavedChat