Underground Pizza

3 Hanover Square #2615, New York, NY 10004, USA 4.6 Stars on Google
Opening Hours
  • Monday: 10:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Tuesday: 10:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Wednesday: 10:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Thursday: 10:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Friday: 10:00 AM – 8:30 PM
  • Saturday: 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Sunday: Closed
Directions Website
8Good signals

Out of 10.0 review consistency and reported experiences

10 Relevant Reviews
Latest: 2 months ago

AI Summary

Analyzed 10 reviews, including 10 Google Users and 0 WiseBites Members. Reviewers reported that staff prepared separate gluten‑free pizzas, asked about gluten‑free needs, and cleaned the oven and preparation area before cooking. Guests mentioned no reported illness and that the handling procedures were intended to minimize cross‑contact.

Was this summary helpful?

User Photos0

No photos yet

Add a review with photos to be the first to show what this restaurant looks like.

Leave a Review

Sign up to share your gluten-free experience with the community.

Sign Up to Review

Community Reviews 0

No community reviews yet

Be the first to share your gluten-free experience at this restaurant.

Mentioned Reviews From Google

"The owner was so patient and friendly. We arrived with four kids who could not agree on a selection and he was so patient and made us all feel so…"

Timothy G.
2 months ago

"Went here with my son. He has to eat gluten free and I do not. This place has 2 different kinds of gluten free crust. The owner took our order, asked…"

Scott D.
4 months ago

"The owner of this place is a legend! Red carpet service and even made a separate gluten free pizza for my wife that was awesome! Top notch food and…"

Greg A.
4 months ago
Read full reviews on Google

Nearby Restaurants

Springy Burgers & Fries

Good signals

74 Pearl St, New York, NY 10004, USA

Analyzed 7 reviews, 0 WiseBites Premium Members, 0 WiseBites Members, and 7 Google Users. Reviewers reported that the gluten‑free burgers, buns, fries, and milkshakes were indistinguishable from regular items, that food was prepared fresh in view of customers, and that staff were helpful; several reviewers described the establishment as a fully gluten‑free eatery. No reviewers mentioned cross‑contamination incidents or illness.

Based on 7 gluten-related reviews

Toro Loco

Mixed signals

15 Stone St, New York, NY 10004, USA

Analyzed 3 reviews, 0 from WiseBites Members and 3 from Google Users. Reviewers reported the restaurant has gluten-free options, including corn tortillas, and knowledgeable staff. Guests mentioned the menu indicates gluten-free options.

Based on 3 gluten-related reviews

Mezcali

Good signals

83 Maiden Ln, New York, NY 10038, USA

Analyzed 6 reviews, 0 WiseBites Members and 6 Google Users. Reviewers reported that staff identified gluten‑friendly items, offered guidance on the menu, and were attentive to gluten sensitivities; no reviewers mentioned cross‑contamination incidents. All comments described positive interactions regarding gluten handling.

Based on 6 gluten-related reviews

The Best Of New York Food

Concerns reported

150 Water St, New York, NY 10005, USA

Analyzed 1 review, with 1 from Google Users and 0 from WiseBites Members. Reviewers reported limited gluten-free options, which are pre-packaged.

Based on 1 gluten-related review

Felice 15 Gold

Good signals

15 Gold St, New York, NY 10038, USA

Analyzed 8 reviews, including 8 Google Users and 0 WiseBites Members. Reviewers reported a variety of gluten‑free pasta dishes, GF bread offered without request, and staff who identified and served gluten‑free items. Guests mentioned that servers were knowledgeable about gluten‑free menu options and took steps to keep those items separate.

Based on 8 gluten-related reviews

Stout NYC

Good signals

90 John St, New York, NY 10038, USA

Analyzed 4 reviews, including 4 Google Users and 0 WiseBites Members. Reviewers reported knowledgeable staff providing gluten-free buns, pizza, and beer options. Guests mentioned a dedicated selection of gluten-free items and a large beer selection that includes gluten-free choices.

Based on 4 gluten-related reviews

SearchExploreSavedChat