Three days of eating gluten-free in New York

Three days of eating gluten-free in New York

Zack Sims 10/30/2026
7
restaurants we reviewed
3
days
Save all 7 to a list

New York had been on our list of American cities to visit because of how prominent the gluten-free scene is. We went that particular weekend to see Harry Styles at Madison Square Garden. Fun fact: Harry Styles and I both ran the 2025 Tokyo Marathon, so it was only right for that to influence my concert outfit.

Zack in a running outfit with his Tokyo Marathon bib, standing with his wife outside Madison Square Garden before the Harry Styles concert

We stayed near Times Square. I think New York had a great gluten-free scene, with far more options and variety than Atlanta. I thought it was more impressive than Chicago, especially just the number of gluten-free options available.

Where we ate

Day 1 · Lunch

Modern Bread and Bagel (Lexington Ave)

9.5Strong signalsDedicated fryerGluten-free menuAnalyzed from 5 Google reviews and 1 WiseBites review

All of their bagels are gluten-free, and they have a really good selection! I do advise getting there earlier, as they can sell out of certain flavors.

This location is probably best for grabbing a bagel and eating on the go. They have several locations, but I recommend hitting at least one of them!

We went later in the day and they had far fewer options left, but it was still really good!

See the review signals for Modern Bread and Bagel (Lexington Ave) →

Day 1 · Dinner

Lilli and Loo

9.0Strong signalsDedicated fryerGluten-free menuAnalyzed from 10 Google reviews and 1 WiseBites review

This place is so awesome! Talk about an extensive gluten-free menu, for the kinds of food you typically can't find gluten-free.

We ordered way too much food, but it was almost impossible not to, given my wife almost never gets the chance to eat Chinese food!

What we ordered: Oriental Pork Dumplings · Crispy General Tso's · Beef & Broccoli

See the review signals for Lilli and Loo →

Day 2 · Brunch

Posh Pop Bakeshop (Upper West Side)

10.0Strong signalsDedicated fryerGluten-free menuAnalyzed from 10 Google reviews and 1 WiseBites review

This is a staple of gluten-free New York! The selection is absolutely unreal, and they have so many options. It is 100% gluten-free, and the staff was so welcoming.

We ordered way too much food, haha, but it's almost impossible not to! I would 100% go back and recommend it to anyone.

What we ordered: Fried Oreos · Salty Sweet Chipper (chocolate chip cookie topped with potato chips) · Ham & Cheese Crepe (savory crepe filled with Black Forest ham and cheddar cheese) · Chocolate Strawberry Crepe (sweet crepe filled with strawberry, chocolate and powdered sugar) · S'mores Bar (a blondie baked with chocolate chips, filled with marshmallow, on a honey graham cracker crust)

See the review signals for Posh Pop Bakeshop (Upper West Side) →

Day 2 · Dinner

Serano's Italian

8.5Strong signalsDedicated fryerGluten-free menuAnalyzed from 10 Google reviews and 1 WiseBites review

They have a very large gluten-free menu, and the food was sooo good! The Hot Louie Pizza is so freaking good.

This is a must if you need good gluten-free food in NYC. I would suggest making a reservation!

What we ordered: Hot Louie Pizza (vodka sauce, pepperoni, stracciatella, Calabrian chili, honey) · A panini

See the review signals for Serano's Italian →

Day 3 · Brunch

Friedman's (Hell's Kitchen)

8.8Strong signalsDedicated fryerGluten-free menuAnalyzed from 10 Google reviews and 1 WiseBites review

All of their entrees are naturally gluten-free, which allows for a lot of options! They can also make sandwiches gluten-free by subbing in gluten-free bread.

The staff was very knowledgeable about making food gluten-free, and they have gluten-free chicken and waffles! They have many locations around NYC.

What we ordered: Chicken & Waffles

See the review signals for Friedman's (Hell's Kitchen) →

Day 3 · Dinner

Senza Gluten

10.0Strong signalsDedicated fryerGluten-free menuAnalyzed from 10 Google reviews and 1 WiseBites review

This was a really cool vibe, and it helps that it is a 100% dedicated gluten-free restaurant! It kind of felt like we were back in Italy.

The food is super good, and we really enjoyed everything. The Gnocchi Ai Quattro was absolutely unreal. One thing to know: they only take cash or American Express!

What we ordered: Gnocchi Ai Quattro (Gorgonzola, fontina, parmesan and mozzarella in cream sauce, with spinach) · Gnocchi Alla Bolognese (homemade potato gnocchi with traditional meat sauce)

See the review signals for Senza Gluten →

Day 3 · Late night

Vinny's Gluten Free Kitchen

8.8Strong signalsDedicated fryerGluten-free menuAnalyzed from 10 Google reviews and 1 WiseBites review

One of the biggest challenges of being gluten-free is finding good late-night food. This place is perfect after a long night out, and we went both nights we went out in NYC!

I think my wife almost cried tears of joy at getting the kind of late-night food she hasn't been able to enjoy in years!

We ordered late night after a long night out in the city, so it was just an assortment of things.

What we ordered: Chicken sandwich · Mac n cheese · Calzone

See the review signals for Vinny's Gluten Free Kitchen →

The ones we ran out of days for

Three days only fits so many meals. These are the ones we would try next, if you have more time than we did.

  • 261 5th Ave, New York
    On Fifth Ave in NoMad, a few blocks from Serano's
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews
  • 1133 Broadway, New York
    On Broadway in NoMad, near Serano's
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews
  • 630 9th Ave, New York
    On Ninth Ave in Hell's Kitchen, a block from Vinny's
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews
  • Wild9.4
    535 Hudson St, New York
    On Hudson St in the West Village
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews
  • 325 Lafayette St, New York
    On Lafayette St in NoHo
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews
  • 309 E 5th St, New York
    In the East Village
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews
  • 2440 Broadway, New York
    On Broadway on the Upper West Side, near Posh Pop
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews
  • 77 Fulton St, New York
    On Fulton St in the Financial District
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews
  • 235 Murray St, New York
    In Battery Park City
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews
  • 1260 Madison Ave, New York
    On Madison Ave on the Upper East Side
    Analyzed from 10 Google reviews

What I would tell you before you go

Map out the subway and plan ahead. It can be confusing if you come from a city that doesn't have a lot of public transit!

Get to Modern Bread and Bagel early. They sell out, and later in the day there are far fewer options.

Make a reservation at Serano's.

Bring cash or an American Express card to Senza Gluten. They only take cash or Amex.

We post what we eat on TikTok as we travel. If you want to see where we eat next, follow along at @zslims5.

Planning your own trip? Save all of these to a list on WiseBites and take the whole guide with you, with the review signals attached.

SearchExploreSavedChat